|
|
|
|
|---|
Literacy Overview |
All students, including those with significant disabilities, should be provided high quality instruction to engage in meaningful literacy activities. Many students with complex learning needs have been denied access to opportunities which foster literacy success, based upon the erroneous assumption that they could not benefit from this instruction. There is now an emerging body of research in support of literacy instruction for students with significant disabilities. While some students may not acquire generalized reading skills, literacy skills are “functional” and can enhance a student’s quality of life and lead to improved adult outcomes.
The Louisiana Department of Education (LDE), in partnership with LEAs across the state, is supporting the Ensuring Literacy and Numeracy for All project. The intent of this project is to make sure every student in Louisiana is a successful reader, writer, and mathematician. In this instance, ALL really does mean all - including students with the most significant cognitive disabilities. For that reason, stakeholders at the state, regional, district, building, and classroom levels must incorporate the needs of students with significant disabilities into the planning, implementation, and evaluation of their literacy initiative efforts.
Action Steps Recommendations Chart (2011-2012)
A chart providing a list of literacy support recommendations for students with significant disabilities for school year 2011-2012 from the LDE, along with resources to support these recommendations, can be found at the following link: http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Literacy/Literacy%20Support%20Recommendations%20September%202011.docx
All students, including those with significant disabilities, should be included in district-wide literacy/reading assessments (e.g., DIBELS Next). If use of the typical assessment(s) does not provide sufficient information, there are a variety of other assessment tools that can be used in addition to assessment tools used by districts. The tools do not take the place of other assessments required by districts such as the DIBELS.
The Access Guide provides a variety of tools and resources for use by educators and family members in the design, implementation, and evaluation of literacy based programs for students with significant disabilities. Additional tools to support literacy access for these students can be found under the Resources/Tools tab. | Quality Indicators for Literacy Access (Significant Disabilities) |
The draft Quality Indicators for Literacy Access (Significant Disabilities) was developed through the Louisiana Department of Education. The document is designed to provide guidance to educators and families on the provision of literacy opportunities for students with significant cognitive disabilities. Indicators are organized in the following areas: assessment, IEP, instruction, evaluation, administrative support, professional development, and resources.
| K-3 Literacy Assessments for Students with Low Incidence Disabilities during 2011-2012 |
Via a July 28, 2011 memo, the Louisiana Department of Education provided guidance to local school districts on issues related to K-3 literacy assessments for students who:
1) have a significant cognitive disability (i.e., students who either currently participate in LEAP Alternate Assessment, Level 1, or will likely qualify for this assessment program at some point in the future),
2) are Blind/Visually Impaired, or
3) are Deaf/Hard of Hearing.
Refer to the documents provided below for guidance on assessment administration, reporting requirements, as well as resources.
July 28, 2011 memo from Dr. Kerry Laster
DIBELS Next Guidance – Students with Significant Disabilities
Reporting Requirements – Students with Significant Disabilities
Resources for Literacy Assessments – Students with Significant Disabilities
Sample Assessment Tools – Students with Significant Disabilities
DIBELS Next Guidance – Students who are Blind/Visually Impaired
Reporting Requirements – Students who are Blind/Visually Impaired
DIBELS Next Guidance – Students who are Deaf/Hard of Hearing
Reporting Requirements – Students who are Deaf/Hard of Hearing | Literacy Assessment Tools: Sample Options for Students with Significant Disabilities |
This chart, Sample Assessment Tools, compiled by Dr. Caroline Musselwhite, contains information regarding a variety of assessment tools that can be used to assess the literacy/reading progress of a student with a significant disability. One or more of these tools can be used in addition to assessment tools used by districts. These tools do not take the place of other assessments required by districts such as the DIBELS (Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills).
One assessment tool described in the above referenced chart is The BRIDGE (Pierce, Summer, O’DeKirk, in progress). An example is provided here (BRIDGE photograph samples) of images of a Louisiana student engaged in various literacy activities outlined in the assessment tool.
| Literacy Folder |
The Louisiana Department of Education recommends that a Literacy Folder be initiated for all students with significant disabilities (click on Literacy Folder Overview for a complete description). The Literacy Folder is an individual student folder that will follow the student across grades and will provide a clear picture of growth in literacy learning. The intent is to help teachers, therapists, and others quickly access previous assessment information, sample portfolio pieces, and materials, strategies, and programs that have been implemented. This folder will look different for preschool, elementary, middle school, and high school students.
The Literacy Folder is essential to provide a seamless transition in student literacy accomplishments and needs across grade levels. For students with significant disabilities, assessment can be arduous and time-consuming. It is crucial to retain assessment data, including informal assessment to chart progress, but also to avoid wasting valuable time. Portfolio pieces across time will help educators plot change across a longer time span than a single school year. Current teachers will be able to find information such as materials and programs that were successfully used with each student, and special interests that support literacy efforts.
The Literacy Experiences Summary is a chart which can be incorporated in the use of the Literacy Folder. It is intended to provide a ‘snapshot’ of the student’s literacy experiences through the school year. Several blocks are purposely left blank, so that the team can summarize information that will provide additional support for the next team working with this student.
Click here for images from one Louisiana district where Literacy Folders are being used to track students' access and outcomes related to literacy.
Although the Literacy Folder Overview and Literacy Experiences Summary are in draft format, the Louisiana Department of Education is encouraging their use. Please submit any feedback regarding the documents to: nanette.olivier@la.gov
| Assessment Flow Chart (What to do if standard literacy assessment tools aren't sufficient.) |
The Assessment Flow Chart provides an illustration of the process to follow if standard literacy/reading tests and materials used to assess every student (e.g., DIBELS, developmental spelling tests) are not providing sufficient information about the progress/strengths/needs of a student with a significant disability | Literacy Rubric (Kathy Staugler, 2007) (Informal literacy assessment tool) |
The Literacy Rubric reprinted here with permission from the author, Kathy Staugler, can be used to conduct an informal literacy assessment of a student with a significant disability. The rubric addresses the five components of reading instruction across three levels of literacy engagement: Early Emerging Literacy, Transitional Emerging Literacy, and Early Conventional. | 1-Minute Writing Context Checklist |
The 1-Minute Context Checklist is designed to support teachers of students with significant disabilities in saving student writing samples that permit comparison across time. Click here for a PowerPoint file containing photographs of a student's writing which was tracked using the 1-Minute Context Checklist. | Assessing Developmental Spelling |
Developmental spelling is important because it gives us a "window" into children's understanding of how to use print to form words, and how those understandings grow across time. Across time, individuals go through predictable "phases" of developmental spelling. The Monster Test of developmental spelling can identify the current phase of spelling, and show progress across time and across interventions.
The two documents provided here include an overview of the Monster Test of developmental spelling, which was designed by Rick Generty and colleagues in 1985, along with ideas for adapting the test for use with students who need accommodations.
Monster Test Introduction: Assessing Developmental Spelling
Monster Test: Administration | Every Day Chart (Provide literacy support for every child every day!) |
The Every Day Chart, compiled by Dr. Caroline Musselwhite, is designed to show teachers the types of literacy activities that EVERY student should engage in EVERY day. Thus, the opportunity to choose books and read or listen independently, and to write using accessible tools, should happen on a daily basis, not just occasionally. Looking at this chart from top to bottom also shows how a student’s skills in one area, such as interacting with a group leader around text, might grow across a year. For assessment and planning support, see the Bridge protocol (link provided in the chart). | Literacy Action Step Chart 2011-2012 |
This chart (click here) provides a list of literacy support recommendations for students with significant disabilities for school year 2011-2012 from the Louisiana Department of Educaiton, along with resources to support these recommendations. | Literacy Articles (significant disabilities) |
Research-Based Practices for Creating Access to the General Curriculum in Reading and Literacy for Students with Significant Intellectual Disabilities (Erickson, Hanser, Hatch, &Sanders, 2009) was developed by the Center for Literacy and Disability Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The publication provides an extensive review of research-based practices and their implications for literacy instruction for students with significant disabilities.
The Beginning Literacy Framework by Karen Erickson, Caroline Musselwhite, and Ruth Ziolkowski (2002) focuses on reading needs for students with significant disabilities:
• Materials that Match their Ability
• Opportunities to Read (including both light and high-tech materials)
• Standards-based Materials
This framework helps educators choose and create books that match needs of students for enrichment, transitional, and conventional texts. | Emergent Literacy Goals |
The Center for Literacy and Disability Studies at the University of North Carolina has posted sample IEP literacy goals for students who are just getting started with literacy. These examples cover a range of literacy issues and may assist IEP teams in developing meaningful targets for students with the most significant disabilities. Refer to the link below at the Center's website:
| Top Ten Tips for Literacy! (Supporting Students with Significant Disabilities) |
Dr. Musselwhite, internationally known for her work in the areas of assistive technology and literacy support for students with significant disabilities, has granted permission to post her “Top Ten Tips for Literacy” related to literacy access for students with significant disabilities. Click on each of the topics listed below for great strategies that you might try in your own classroom!
See more tips at:
www.aacintervention.com
| Literacy and Significant Disabilities - Websites, Blogs, Wikis, and Nings |
This document, Websites, Blogs, Wikis, and Nings, contains a list of helpful websites related to literacy access for students with significant disabilities. Also provided is a description of each site. | Literacy Access Images (photos, video clips) |
Through the use of photographs and video clips, this section of the Access Guide provides examples of adaptations, modifications, and supports used to actively engage students with significant disabilities in literacy activities. NOTE: Additional photographs and video clips specific to the use of "alternate pencils" are posted under the "Alternate Pencil" heading under the Literacy tool bar.
Photographs
The documents listed below provide photographic images of students engaged in literacy activities. To open the documents, simply click on the highlighted titles.
Photographs of adaptations and modifications used to teach literacy with the use of Attainment’s “Early Literacy Skill Building” program
Accessing Literacy Using a Variety of Methods
General Literacy Support Pictures (1)
General Literacy Support Pictures (2)
General Literacy Support Pictures (3)
General Literacy Support Pictures (4)
Video Clips
The following chart provides links to brief video clips of students with significant disabilities engaged in literacy activities. Information is included regarding the type of activity/strategy depicted in the video clips, as well as the Extended Standards addressed. NOTE: The examples are listed in grade level order (K -12th grade).
When observing these clips, consider the following points:
- Level of student engagement in activity
- Adaptation/modifications linked to student needs
- Clarity of instruction
- Learning outcomes for student
- Age appropriateness
- Strategies that might be used to include this instruction within the context of a general education class/activity
|
Video clips
(minutes:
seconds)
|
Grade level |
Extended Standards |
Activity description/strategy |
|
Reading at Elementary School
Part 1 (2:38)
Part 2 (3:08) |
1st - 2nd |
ELA
ES-42/37: Use listening strategies |
Students are engaged in a reading activity using different techniques (searching, pointing, touching, reading, questions, big vs. little, M (mmmm) sound, repeating words).
Observe: instruction on components of reading, use of assistive technology to support engagement |
|
Reading – Symbol manipulation increases attention
(1:03) |
K, 1st, 3rd |
ELA
ES-8/5: Identify story elements, including: characters
Benchmarks/GLEs:
Kindergarten:
ELA-1-E1, ELA-1-E2, ELA-1-E4, ELA-1-E5, ELA-7-E3
First Grade:
ELA-1-E4, ELA-4-E4, ELA-1-E1, ELA-7-E1
Third Grade:
ELA-1-E4, ELA-7-E1
|
As the teacher reads a big book to the students, each student is given a job to Velcro pictures or repetitive story lines onto the book pages. This increases attention and engagement in the lesson because they feel they are an important part of reading the story. This also increases comprehension because the students are matching story pictures and repetitive story lines.
Note: Pictures were created using Picture It! Software. Repetitive story line cards were created using Boardmaker software. |
|
Reading-
Differentiated responses to predict outcomes (1:02) |
K, 1st, 3rd |
ELA
ES-22/20: Write a composition that is organized with: central idea and a logical, sequential order.
Benchmarks/GLEs:
Kindergarten
ELA-1-E5, ELA-7-E2, ELA-2-E1, ELA-2-E3, ELA-2-E6, ELA-3-E5
First Grade
ELA-7-E2, ELA-2-E6
Third Grade
ELA-7-E2, ELA-3-E1
|
The teacher created 3 differentiated levels based on the student’s instructional level.
Level 1 – The teacher created a sentence cloze worksheet and the student had to choose a picture of an animal to complete the sentence cloze. The student will glue the picture onto the paper under the cloze. (Note: Photos were from Picture It! Software.)
Level 2 – The teacher created a sentence cloze worksheet and presented the students with 3 choices of possible outcomes using Boardmaker software. The student chose the picture and glued onto sentence cloze then drew a picture to support the sentence. Level 3 – The teacher created a sentence starter worksheet and the student had to think of another possible outcome to the book and write on the lines of the worksheet. The student then drew a picture to support the sentence. (Modification – The student could dictate & the teacher could write on paper or have the student copy the dictation.) |
|
Interdisciplinary Connections- Numeracy & Science in the midst of Literacy
(0:27) |
K, 1st, 3rd |
ELA
ES-8/5: Identify story elements, including: character
ES-42/37: Use listening strategies
Science
ES-A1 Classify objects based on properties (size, color, numbers)
Benchmarks/GLEs include: Kindergarten (ELA, math, science)
1st grade (ELA, Math, science)
3rd grade (ELA, science) |
The teacher reads the book and asks comprehension questions. The teacher guides the students to describe the fish using colors, numbers, and size words.
Note: This extension activity is provided by Unique Learning System in the March Elementary lesson plans. |
|
Enthusiasm Influences Learning!
(0:57) |
K, 1st, 3rd |
ELA
ES-8/5: Identify story elements, including: character
ES-42/37: Use listening strategies
Science
ES-A1 Classify objects based on properties (size, color, numbers)
Benchmarks/GLEs also include: Kindergarten (ELA, math, science)
1st grade (ELA, math, science)
3rd grade (ELA, science) |
The teacher will read the book and ask comprehension questions. The teacher is excited and engages the students during the reading and in turn the students are excited about reading the book which decreases behavior issues.
Note: This extension activity is provided by Unique Learning System in the March Elementary lesson plans. |
|
Composing sentences using symbols
Part 1 – 0:33
Part 2 – 1:09 |
K, 1st, 3rd |
ELA
ES-22/20: Write a composition that is organized with: central idea and a logical, sequential order.
Science
ES-A1 Classify objects based on properties (size, color, numbers)
Benchmarks/GLEs:
Kindergarten (ELA, Math, Science)
First Grade (ELA, Science) |
The students will compose sentences using describing words such as color, numbers, and size words. The teacher will provide the sentence cloze and picture icons to complete the sentences. The sentences will be based upon the students’ individual levels.
Level 1 – The teacher will provide a laminated copy of the sentence cloze worksheet with picture icons that will be velcroed. The teacher will give the students picture choices & the student will Velcro 1 size word picture (small, medium, large), 1 color word picture, and 1 number word picture into sentence cloze. The student will then find the appropriate fish cut outs and place onto top of page. The student will repeat for each size word: small medium, large.
Level 2 – The teacher will provide the student with 3 copies of the sentence cloze worksheet and copies of the fish cutouts and picture icons. The student will make a page for each size word picture and choose their own color & number pictures. The students will glue the picture icons on the sentence cloze then get the appropriate amount & correct size fish cutouts and color to match their sentence. Then glue the fish to the top of each page to support the sentence.
Level 3 - The teacher will provide the student with 3 copies of the sentence cloze worksheet and copies of the fish cutouts and picture icons. The student will make a page for each size word picture and choose their own color & number pictures. The students will write the words from the picture icons on the sentence cloze then get the appropriate amount & correct size fish cutouts and color to match their sentence. Then glue the fish to the top of each page to support the sentence.
Note – Materials are provided in an extension activity by Unique Learning System in the March Elementary Unit lesson plans. |
|
Small, Medium, Large Comparison Activity
(0:33) |
K, 1st, 3rd |
Science
ES-A1 Classify objects based on properties (size, color, numbers)
Benchmarks/GLEs:
ELA
Kindergarten
ELA-4-E3
Math
Kindergarten
M-3-E, M-1-E, M-2-E, G-2-E
First Grade
G-3-E, G-2-E
|
The teacher will present Early Language Concept Kits – Comparing Sizes. (Kit available at Lakeshore Learning) The teacher will guide the students to complete one card through guided practice then complete 1-2 cards independently to check for comprehension of size words.
Note – If you do not have a comparing sizes kit you can still practice the skill by going to the English/Language Arts Unit link and looking under the Stone Soup unit for some additional activities. |
|
Early Literacy Skills Builder session
Preparation (:28)
Class Participation(1:57)
Touching Words (:52)
Reading Sentences (2:12)
Read-Sing-Touch (2:26) |
1st-2nd |
|
Multiple students are engaged in a reading lesson using the Early Literacy Skills Builder program.
Observe: different needs of students and how these needs are accomodated/supported in the instructional section |
|
Beginning Engagement in Literacy (1:51)
Joint attention (:00 - :15)
Student interaction
(:16 – 1:02)
Skimming and Scanning (1:03 – 1:51) |
3rd-4th |
ELA
ES- 8/5: Identify story elements, including: character
ES- 21/19: Apply basic reasoning skills, including: skimming and scanning text for specific information (field of two)
ES-38/35: Follow simple directions |
Students are engaged in the foundations of reading a book – Book knowledge/ Appreciation/Print Awareness/Story Comprehension (from The BRIDGE. Pierce, Summer, O’DeKirk, in progress).
Students display joint attention while being read to.
Students interact with symbols/print.
Observe: Teacher using a least to most prompting strategy to introduce skimming and scanning to make choice from a field of two. |
|
Partner Four word review(1:54) |
3rd-4th |
ELA
ES-1/1: Reading and responding
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
ELA-1-E1 |
Through consistent use of manual signing and graphic symbols, the student demonstrates his ability to understand and use the symbols. He utilizes a Partner Four to communicate the vocabulary words for the weekly story. The student is engaged in The Early Literacy Skills Builder reading series developed by Dr. Diane Browder. |
|
Counting and one-to-one correspondence
(1:17) |
3rd - 4th |
MATH
ES-1/1: Read and write place value
3. Read and/or write numbers
2. Identify numbers
1. Count objects to a given number.
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
N-1-E |
The teacher models for the students how to roll the die, count and stamp the correct number using one-to-one correspondence. The students are highly engaged and interested in the activity. Rolling the die and using the ink blotter are also addressing fine motor skills. |
|
Literacy and writing (1:47) |
3rd - 4th |
ELA
ES-1/1: Reading and responding
ES-27/26: Write for various purposes
ES-42/37: Use listening strategies.
EX-17/14: Understanding information in text
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
ELA-1-E1, ELA-2-E6
ELA-7-E1 |
The teacher engages the students in literacy activities by stating the title and setting a purpose for reading the book by looking for specific information and vocabulary. Writing is modeled by the teacher before the students are given unprompted writing opportunities. The students’ writings are then read back for reinforcement and further modeling. |
|
“Chunking” activity (1:17) |
3rd - 4th |
ELA
ES-1/1: Reading and responding.
Benchmarks/GLE’s: ELA-1-E1 |
This group of students works with the teacher in “chunking” words into syllables. “Chunking” is an activity used to teach phonics skills with The Early Literacy Skills Builder reading series developed by Dr. Diane Browder. Physical support is provided for some of the students, while one student decides to complete the activity independently. |
|
Writing with an Expanded Keyboard
(1:45) |
3rd-4th |
ELA
ES- 21/19: Apply basic reasoning skills, including: skimming and scanning text for specific information
ES- 17/14: Demonstrate an understanding of information in texts
· identifying main idea
· sequencing events
ES- 22/20: Write a composition that is organized with
· central idea
· logical, sequential order |
Teacher/student utilizing expanded keyboard to write about a story read.
Maximum prompting used by teacher to keep student engaged in the activity.
Student able to independently write last sentence with an “errorless” technique. |
|
Alternate Pencil(1:15) |
3rd |
ELA
ES-42/37: Use listening strategies |
Student is engaged in a reading activity using a communication device to select a word. |
|
Reading for Multiple Purposes (1:30) |
|
|
Students read The Very Hungry Catepillar multiple times for multiple purposes (e.g., title, main character). |
|
Word Wall (1:03) |
|
|
Students select words related to text (The Very Hungry Catepillar) for word wall. |
|
Interactive Board-Old MacDonald (0:42) |
5th |
ES-12/11
Demonstrate understanding of information in text, including sequencing events and making predictions
ES-17/16
Demonstrate understanding of text by using reasoning skills, including: cause and effect.
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
ELA-7-M4 ELA-4-M4 |
Student actively engaging in independent reading with a song on an interactive board. Student interacts with symbols, makes predictions, turns pages (advances slides), listens (phonemic awareness), participates verbally and demonstrates shared/joint attention with class. |
|
Adapted Book-Reading Group(0:52) |
5th-6th |
ES-4/3
Develop a vocabulary of common content-specific words
ES-12/11
Demonstrate understanding of information in texts, including sequencing events and making predictions
ES-38/37
Demonstrate active listening skills
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
ELA-1-M2, ELA-7-M1, ELA-4-M4 |
Small group of students who are non-verbal reading an adapted book with a repeatable line. A single switch voice output device is used to facilitate verbalizations with correct timing during book reading. Students use symbols during book reading demonstrating comprehension and increased vocabulary knowledge. |
|
Introducing Counting
(0:28) |
5th-6th |
ES-8/9
Add and subtract numbers
Benchmark/GLE’s: N-5-M |
Student engages in counting activity on an interactive board using Early Learning I software by Marblesoft. Teacher demonstrates prompting student to succeed by modeling the correct number via pointing on the board. |
|
Daily Sign In(0:52) |
5th-6th |
ES-25/24
Write for various purposes
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
ELA-2-M6 |
Teacher offers choices of colored markers to students to expand communication opportunities during daily writing routine. Students sign in authentically as teacher follows up with modeling of printing child’s name. |
|
Supporting Independent Reading with AAC
(2:12) |
5th-6th |
ELA
ES- 4/3: Develop a vocabulary of common content-specific words.
ES- 17/16: Demonstrate understanding of text by using reasoning skills, including:
· skimming and scanning
· cause and effect |
This student participated in class readings of a higher level version of this Unique Learning Intermediate book. She is somewhat prompt dependent and her speech is unintelligible in unknown contexts. She is working on becoming more independent with activities. This version of the book was given to her as an independent reader that she can take home and read to her family.
Observe:
Student pointing to words to indicate she has an understanding of text. (:09)
Student using picture cues to read words. (:16)
Student reading word then pointing to correct picture to verify comprehension. (:40)
Dots were used to assist student with attending to reading each word. (:49)
Student using learned scanning technique to locate word on device. (:59) |
|
Identifying Vocabulary Using Symbols (:46) |
ELA
5th-6th
Science
8th |
ELA
ES-4/3: Develop a vocabulary of common content-specific words
Science ES-C3: Recognize that different types of familiar animals are suited to different habitats (i.e., ocean, lake/river, forest, grassland, desert) |
Students identify vocabulary words using symbols then read lesson on Biomes. |
|
Checking for Understanding (:36) |
ELA
5th-6th
9th-11th
Science
8th |
ELA 9-11: ES-11/11 - Demonstrate understanding of information in texts, including: summarizing information, comparing and contrasting literary elements and ideas within and among texts, sequencing events or procedures, making inferences, drawing conclusions, making predictions about a story |
Student identifies different Biomes after lessons on ecosystems |
|
Informal Assessment Using Symbols
(2:06) |
ELA
5th-6th
9th-11th
Science
8th |
ELA 9-11: ES-11/11 - Demonstrate understanding of information in texts, including: summarizing information, comparing and contrasting literary elements and ideas within and among texts, sequencing events or procedures, making inferences, drawing conclusions, making predictions about a story
ELA 5-6: ES-4/3 - Develop a vocabulary of common content-specific words
Science 8: ES-C3 - Recognize that different types of familiar animals are suited to different habitats (i.e., ocean, lake/river, forest, grassland, desert) |
Students categorize plants and animal into the correct Biomes after lessons on ecosystems. |
| Reading with Story Boxes (0:39) |
6th |
This student is addressing the access skills of attending to the story and indicating to a partner when to turn the page. |
The student is engaged in listening to a simple, age-appropriate story from Tarheel Reader. Exploring a Story Box containing story related sensory objects increases engagement and supports comprehension for students with visual impairments and students with more significant cognitive disabilities.
Observe: Note the use of wait time in the video. Students with more complex needs often require a longer period of time to process and respond to stimuli. Appropriate use of wait time enhances student learning. For students with the most complex needs wait time as long as 30-60 seconds may be necessary in the beginning.
Also note that the teacher attributes meaning to the student’s behavior, waving, to shape the behavior into an intentional gesture for communicating “I’m finished” or “I want to stop.” |
|
AAC Supports Class Discussion
(1:03) |
6th-8th |
ES-38/38: Participate in a group discussion |
Using augmentative communication strategies allows students who are non-verbal to participate in class discussions. These students are brainstorming ideas for a group writing activity about a story they have read. |
|
Alternate Pencils
Writing with Alternate Pencils: Scanning
(1:35)
Writing with Alternate Pencils : Direct Selection – Low Tech
(1:14)
Writing with Alternate Pencils: Direct Selection – High Tech
(0:35) |
6th-8th |
Grades 5-6
ES-15/15: Write a composition
Grades 7-8
ES-22/22: Write for various purposes |
Alternate Pencils provide access to writing with for students who are unable to hold a traditional pencil. Students are presented with all 26 letters of the alphabet and dictate their choices using either scanning or direct selection. During each writing session, the teacher models use of the student’s alternate pencil, the student writes, and the student reads back his writing. Writing with Alternate Pencils allows students with significant disabilities to develop beginning writing skills in the same way as typical students at the emergent writing level.
The three students in the videos show three different methods of accessing writing. All three students are at the very beginning emergent stage of writing. The instructional focus is on the process of “scribbling” with their alternate pencils rather than attempting to spell or produce a specific end product. Meaning is attached to their choices when possible to increase engagement and to highlight sound/symbol relations. Students who are non-verbal use their communication devices to read back their writing.
Observe: Note in the first video, Writing with Alternate Pencils: Scanning, how the teacher incorporates recording the student’s writing on the device into the teaching session.
In the third video, Writing with Direct Selection – High Tech, note the use of a tactile Braille overlay on the Intellitools board, the use of hand-under-hand modeling, and reinforcement of left-to-right fingering.
When writing was first introduced, some students actively resisted participating by irritated vocalizations, turning their heads away, and pushing materials away. One student simply seemed unaware of the materials or the teacher’s modeling or instruction. With continued exposure and modeling over several months, the students have begun to actively participate in the writing process. Additionally, growth has been seen in areas such as intentional responding, switch use, cause/effect relations, attending to task, social interaction and communication skills.
Additional information on "writing with alternate pencils" is available on the following links:
http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/Site%20Pages/LiteracyView.aspx
http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/available-for-purchase-1/available-for-purchase
http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/resources/deaf-blind-model-classroom-resources/Emerg%20Wrtg%20Obs%20Inventory.pdf/view http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/resources/deaf-blind-model-classroom-resources/EmergentLiteracyGoals2009.pdf?searchterm=iep |
|
Beginning Writing
(0:43) |
7th |
ES-22/22: Write for various purposes |
Modeling rather than copying or hand-over-hand assistance is used to instruct a beginning writer. Using this approach the student has increased time on task from 5-10 seconds to over 15 minutes. He now produces more than 30 marks per session and uses a variety of pre-writing strokes. He is now being exposed to letter writing.
Observe: Note the “High 5” reinforcement at the end. Hitting to request attention is being shaped into the more socially appropriate behavior of giving a “High 5.” |
| Interactive Board- Reviewing Story Elements (:48) |
9th-12th |
ELA
ES-2/2: Identify story elements
ES-11/11: Demonstrate understanding of information in texts
ES-29/32: Follow procedures for complex procedures/routines
Benchmarks/GLE’s
ELA-1-H2, ELA-7-H1,
ELA-4-H2 |
This video clip shows a student using a Promethean Board to complete a teacher-made ActivInspire activity. The activity reviews story elements (title, author, main idea and setting) of a Start to Finish Literacy Starter book (Don Johnston, Inc.). |
|
Interactive Board- Reviewing Vocabulary
(:27) |
9th-12th |
ELA
ES-11/11: Demonstrate understanding of information in texts
ES-29/32: Follow procedures for complex procedures/routines
ES-35/38: Participate in a group discussion
Benchmarks/GLE’s
ELA-7-H1, ELA-4-H2, ELA-4-H6 |
This video clip shows a student using a Promethean Board to complete a teacher-made ActivInspire activity assisted by the para-professional. The activity uses text, pictures and voice recordings to review vocabulary words. |
|
Interactive Board- Spelling
(:46) |
9th – 12th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines
ES-35/38: Participate in a group discussion, including- acting as facilitator
Benchmarks/GLE’s:
ELA-4-H2, ELA-4-H6 |
This video clip shows a student using a Promethean Board to complete a teacher-made spelling lesson. The lesson was created using ActivInspire Software. |
|
Interactive Board- Vocabulary Picture Find
(:52) |
9th-12th |
ELA
ES-11/11: Demonstrate understanding of information in texts
ES-29/32: Follow procedures for complex procedures/routines
ES-35/38: Participate in a group discussion
Benchmarks/GLE’s
ELA-7-H1, ELA-4-H2,
ELA-4-H6 |
This video clip shows a group of students using a Promethean Board to complete a teacher-made ActivInspire activity. The activity requires the students to drag a circle over each vocabulary picture. |
| Interactive Board- Geometry Vocabulary (1:18) |
9th-12th |
Math
ES-7/4 Use basic concepts of proportional reasoning in real life situations
ES-26/14 Identify a simple transformation
ES-28/22 Use data in real life situations
Benchmarks/GLE’s
N-6-H, G-3-8, D-7-8 |
This video clip shows a student playing a Geometry vocabulary dice game. The die was created using a simple “mailing” box and Geometry vocabulary words/pictures inserted into the CD sleeves (glued on each side of the box). The teacher-made interactive chart was created with ActivInspire software and a Promethean Board is used for chart access. |
|
Reading-Using Voice Output Device
(:34) |
9th-12th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines
ES-35/38: Participate in a group discussion (when used with more than 1 student)
Benchmarks/GLE’s
ELA-4-H2, ELA-4-H6 |
This video clip shows a teacher assisting a student in using a Penfriend (voice output device) to read a Start to Finish Literacy Starter book. The teacher has recorded the digital version of the book onto the Penfriend. |
|
Using Technology to Create Graphs and Charts
(:55) |
9th-11th |
ES-28/22: Use data in real-life situations |
Student uses technology, a SMART Board, to create a chart/bar graph. Used as reinforcement activity and assessment. |
|
Using Picture Symbols to Make a Presentation(2:01) |
9th-11th |
ES-35/38: Participate in a group discussion, including: acting as facilitator, time keeper, leader, listener, or mediator evaluating the effectiveness of participant’s performance
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines |
Student makes presentation on biome. Other students listen and ask questions. Para educator is guiding the lesson. |
|
Counting Money: One Up Method (:41) |
9th-11th |
ES-6/1: Identify and solve simple computation problems
ES-9/10: Model and solve equations using pictures, objects, and letters that relate to real-life relationships |
Student using “One Up” strategy to count money. |
|
Spelling (:37) |
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines
ES-29/32: Participate in a group discussion (when done with other students)
|
Review a spelling lesson created in PowerPoint. |
|
Using Technology to Extend ABC Patterns
(1:08)
Using Technology to Extend AB Patterns I
(:24)
Using Technology to Extend AB Patterns II
(1:08) |
9th-11th |
ES-37/27 – Analyze and extend a pattern |
Student uses technology, a SMART Board, to extend a pattern. Used as reinforcement activity and assessment. |
|
Reading Assessment (Errorless) - One choice scanning
(:38)
|
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines
ES-2/2: Identify story elements
ES-11/11: Demonstrate understanding of information in texts |
After completing literacy unit, assess comprehension via electronic test. This student is learning the routine of responding to assessment questions.
|
|
Reading Assessment – Multiple Choice
(1:00) |
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines
ES-2/2: Identify story elements
ES-11/11: Demonstrate understanding of information in texts |
After completing literacy unit, assess comprehension via multiple choice electronic test. |
|
Reading – Chain Switch Access (:30) |
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines |
Independently read an electronic book using a chain switch. |
|
Reading – Electronic Reader (:44) |
10th |
ESA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routings
ES-29/32: Participate in a group discussion |
Either independently or with a group, read a book using an electronic reader. Observe: student insists upon independence! |
|
Reading – Modified Switch
(:37) |
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines |
Using a modified switch, independently read an electronic book. |
|
Reading – Reviewing Story Elements(:37) |
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines
ES-29/32: Participate in a group discussion
ES-2/2: Identify story elements
ES-11/11: Demonstrate understanding of information in texts |
Review reading comprehension by selecting a question with a spinner device, and by selecting an answer recorded on a communication device. |
|
Reading – Simple Scanning (:29) |
10th |
ELA
ES-29/32: Follow instructions for complex procedures/routines. |
Independently choose and read an electronic book using a switch and a scanning procedure. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Story-based Lesson Task Analyses |
Three sample task analyses for use in conducting story-based lessons are provided here. These have been posted with permission from Dr. Diane Browder. The materials were developed through Project MASTERY/NAAC (IES Grant # H324U040001).
| 2010 Literacy for ALL Celebration! |
Districts and schools across Louisiana are invited to host local literacy and/or numeracy celebration to highlight successes for ALL students, including those with significant disabilities. The Literacy and Numeracy for ALL Celebration flyer provides suggested activities for the celebration, but participants are encouraged to be creative and generate their own plan.
Plase share your literacy celebration success stories with us by email with a summary and pictures (refer to the flyer). We will try to post some of the submissions on the Access Guide website.
Livingston Parish Literacy Celebration
In response to this invitation for school districts/schools to host a literacy celebration that includes a focus on students with significant disabilities, Livingston Parish held an event that is sure to lead to improved outcomes for students! The district set aside a full school day in March, 2009 to devote to their “celebration.” Using LaSIG2 funds, Livingston provided substitute teachers for approximately 50 teachers to attend the event. Teachers who worked with students with significant disabilities (including autism) were invited. The day included demonstrations of model lessons, literacy activities involving students from various schools, small groups structured for problem-solving and instruction, program displays, and more!
East Baton Rouge Parish Literacy Celebration
In May, 2009, the EBR School System celebrated the literacy projects sponsored by the EBR Significant Disabilities Literacy Access Workgroup. Refer to EBR's ESS Gazette (beginning on page 5) for a description and pictures of the celebration.
| Presentation materials |
Dr. Gretchen Hanser's Students with Significant Disabilities as Writers, Readers and Communicators: Yes They Can! worskhops on 1/24/12 and 1/25/12:
The handouts listed below from the 1/24/12 & 1/25/12 workshops are located on the Center for Literacy and Disability Studies website:
Emergent Writing Interaction Inventory Predictable Chart Writing
Nanette Olivier's LRA presentation, 11/8/2011 in Lafayette, LA.
Literacy for Students with Significant Disabilities: Requirements, Recommendations, and Resources
Dr. Gretchen Hanser's Emergent Literacy for All! worskhops on 9/26/11 and 9/27/11:
-- Agenda
-- Main Handout (PDF of slides)
The handouts below from the 9/26 & 9/27 workshops are located on the Center for Literacy and Disability Studies website: --Emergent Literacy Goals
--Partner Assisted Scanning --Emergent Writing Interaction Inventory --Predictable Chart Writing --Generic Reading Interaction Overlay --Erickson Booklist
PowerPoint slides for the 1/24/11 CEC Super Conference session: Quality Indicators for Literacy Access (Significant Disabilities) (click here). For the information regarding literacy assessment webinars and related materials, click here.
PowerPoint slides for the 12/8/2010 InclusionMATTERS Conference session: All Means All! Literacy Access for Students with Significant Disabilities (click here).
PowerPoint slides for the August 2010 AIM (accessible instructional materials) workshops related to the provision of AIM for students with significant disabilities (click here), and the LaSIG newsletter related to AIM for students with significant disabilities (click here).
PowerPoint slides for the June 15, 2010, LASARD session (Literacy Access for Students with Significant Disabilities: Requirements, recommendations, and resources)
PowerPoint slides for the May 5, 2010 SIG day (Literacy Access for Students with Significant Disabilities: Support at your fingertips!)
PowerPoint slides from the April 27, 2010 East Baton Rouge Parish Literacy and Numeracy Celebration: Keynote address (Nanette Olivier)
Materials from the December 2009 Literacy Institute: Low Incidence Disabilities
· The PowerPoint slides and supplemental handout from the Access Guide: Literacy Supports at Your Finger Tips! session can be found at the two links below: http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/literacy%20institute%20access%20guide%20iteracy%20session.ppt
http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Literacy%20Support%20Recommendations.doc
The PowerPoint slides from Nancy Steele's session can be found here: http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/CommunicationandLiteracy%20LA%2009.ppt
· The PowerPoint slides and resources list from Dr. Christi Carnahan's session can be found at the two links below: http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Carnahan%20Literacy%20Significant%20Disabilities%20Dec%2009%20for%20Email.pptx
http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Literacy%20Resources.doc
Material from the Center for Literacy and Disability Studies
· The PowerPoint slides from the presentation Literacy and Students with Severe Disabilities: The Time is Now! (Pierce, P.) can be found at the link below:
http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/files/early-childhood-resources/EmergentLiteracyandSPH.pdf?searchterm=emergent+literacy+IEP+goals
| Literacy Webinars |
WEBINAR: Literacy in the IEP: Extreme Makeover
Presenter: Dr. Caroline Musselwhite
This webinar, recorded on January 25, 2011, takes a lighthearted (but very meaningful) approach to incorporating literacy targets in IEPs for students with significant disabilities. Dr. Musselwhite guides the listeners to look in their "IEP closets" and decide what to toss out, and what to consider when shopping for new IEP content. The webinar is short (51 minutes), but can help you get started on writing IEPs that prepare the IEP team and the student for success.
Procedures to view the webinar:
In order to view this webinar, you must first download the AT&T participant software at the following website: http://uc.att.com/support/download_attc_participant.html
Please note that this software is only compatible with Windows operating system at this point. You will then be able to open and SAVE the webinar file to your PC for viewing by clicking on the following address:
http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/IEP/Literacy%20in%20the%20IEP_Extreme%20Makeover%20Webinar%20January%202011.vcr
The following are handouts related to the webinar:
WEBINAR: Literacy Assessments (Part 1): Significant Disabilities
Presenters: Dr. Caroline Musselwhite and Nanette Olivier
The Literacy Assessments (Part 1): Significant Disabilities webinar, recorded on October 27, 2010, provides an overview of the literacy assessment requirements related to students with significant disabilities in Louisiana public schools. The Part 1 webinar provides a review of three assessment tools and their use with this population of students: DIBELS, the BRIDGE, and the Literacy Rubric. Also included in the webinar is information about resources available for school personnel to use in supporting implementation efforts.
Procedures to view the webinar (Part 1):
In order to view this webinar, you must first download the AT&T participant software at the following website: http://uc.att.com/support/download_attc_participant.html
Please note that this software is only compatible with Windows operating system at this point. You will then be able to open and SAVE the webinar file to your PC for viewing by clicking on the following address:
The following are handouts related to the Part 1 webinar:
WEBINAR: Literacy Assessments (Part 2): Significant Disabilities
Presenters: Dr. Caroline Musselwhite and Nanette Olivier
The Literacy Assessments (Part 2): Significant Disabilities webinar, recorded on October 27, 2010, focuses primarily on a review of three literacy assessment tool options: Intervention Planning Tool, Early Literacy Checklists, and Development Spelling Test (Monster Test). Webinar participants are encouraged to view Part 1 before viewing Part 2, as Part 1 addresses literacy assessment requirements pertaining to students with significant disabilities. Also included in the Part 2 webinar is information about resources available for school personnel to use in supporting implementation efforts.
Procedures to view the webinar (Part 2):
In order to view this webinar, you must first download the AT&T participant software at the following website: http://uc.att.com/support/download_attc_participant.html
Please note that this software is only compatible with Windows operating system at this point. You will then be able to open and SAVE the webinar file to your PC for viewing by clicking on the following address:
The following are handouts related to the Part 2 webinar:
| Alternate Pencils (including video clips) |
Many students with significant disabilities have very limited, if any, opportunities to write. These students may have physical/motor impairments or cognitive challenges that present barriers to writing in a conventional manner.
The Center for Literacy and Disability Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (refer to http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/) has provided leadership in looking at multiple types of “alternate pencils” for these students. These “pencils” provide alternate ways for students to access the alphabet and begin to engage in the writing process. The Center’s website provides video clips of students with significant disabilities using alternate pencils. Direct links to case studies (Jake and Matthew) are as follows:
http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/projects/deaf-blind-model-classroom/jakes-story
http://www.med.unc.edu/ahs/clds/projects/deaf-blind-model-classroom/matthews-story
Louisiana's Alternate Pencil Initiative
Efforts are underway in several Louisiana school districts to support students in the use of “alternate pencils.” Links to webinars related to this activity are provided below. Images of strategies related to "alternate pencil" use are found in the chart below.
|
Video/Photo Image (click on titles) |
Description |
|
1- Minute Writing Context Checklist |
Student’s use of an alternate pencil strategy to write a story, and use of the 1-Minute Writing Context Checklist to assess student’s progress |
|
Adapted Alternate Pencil Keyboard |
Use of an alternate pencil overlay that has been modified to further assist student with a visual impairment |
|
Magnetic letters |
Use of a cookie sheet with magnetic letters as an alternate pencil tool |
|
Spelling and Math Tasks with Alternate Pencil Inserts |
Alternate pencil use for more advanced tasks |
|
Alternate Pencil- Writing Progression (:48) |
This video clip shows a student’s active progression in emergent writing skills using an alternate pencil. The student uses an Intellikeys adapted keyboard, modified with tactile alphabet stickers. The 1st opportunity is a teacher assisted, guided writing activity, while the 2nd and 3rd opportunities depict independent free writing. The clip spans an entire school year of multiple alternate pencil writing activities and shows the student’s increase in purposeful writing interactions. |
|
Alternate Pencil- Alphabet Flip Chart (1:12)
Alternate Pencil-Reading Back (0:32)
Alternate Pencil-Requesting Finished
(0:28) |
The student is engaged in a “free writing” activity using an alphabet flip chart alternate pencil. The adult uses the partner assisted scanning technique. Vocalizations by the student are recognized as the way of indicating which letter to write. The instructor shapes the behavior to build symbolic communication to use a single switch voice output device to indicate “that’s the one”. Notice how the student is expecting the pattern of letter naming and engagement increases.
Student uses a single cell direct select voice output device to read her writing to others.
Teacher acknowledges students choice to stop writing. Eye gaze, gestures and symbols are used to confirm. |
|
Alternate Pencil-Attributing Meaning (0:47) |
In first experiences with writing, the teacher is giving meaning to the students “reach” to the alternate pencil flip chart. Teacher is shaping the student’s behavior/response by waiting for him to respond and verbally labeling that behavior. As each letter is written, the teacher gives meaning to the letter by stating words that begin with that letter sound. |
|
Interactive board utilized as alternate pencil
(1:18) |
The student engages and actively participates independently in emergent writing skills using the interactive board. Boardmaker Speaking Dynamically Pro (SDP) is used to showcase the alphabet in this keyboard format. He attempts to write his name and explores the sights and sounds of other letter writings as well. The teacher uses some of the student’s chosen letters to model writing words and his name. He enjoys hearing the letter sounds and words read back to him. He accesses the interactive board several times a day to practice his writing skills. |
|
Alternate Pencils
Writing with Alternate Pencils: Scanning
(1:35)
Writing with Alternate Pencils : Direct Selection – Low Tech
(1:14)
Writing with Alternate Pencils: Direct Selection – High Tech
(0:35) |
“Alternate pencils” provide access to writing with for students who are unable to hold a traditional pencil. All 26 letters of the alphabet are presented and students dictate their choices using scanning or direct selection. During each writing session, the teacher models use of the student’s alternate pencil, the student writes, and the student reads back his writing. Writing with alternate pencils allows students with significant disabilities to develop beginning writing skills in the same way as typical students at the emergent writing level.
The videos show three different methods of accessing writing with students at the very beginning emergent stage of writing. Instruction focuses on the process of “scribbling” rather than attempting to spell or produce a specific product. Attaching meaning to students’ choices when possible increases engagement and highlights sound/symbol relations. Students use their communication devices to read back their writing. In addition to developing beginning literacy skills, students have shown progress in intentional responding, switch use, cause/effect relations, attending to task, social interaction and communication skills.
Observe:
Note in the first video, Writing with Alternate Pencils: Scanning, the teacher incorporates recording the student’s writing on the device into the teaching session.
In the third video, Writing with Direct Selection – High Tech, note the use of a tactile Braille overlay on the Intellitools board, the use of hand-under-hand modeling, and reinforcement of left-to-right fingering.
Additional information on "writing with alternate pencils" is available on the following links:
Emergent Literacy Interaction Inventory
Sample IEP Goals
Access Guide - Literacy View
Alternate Pencils |
|
|
|
November 2010 Webinar: Alternate Pencil - Why Bother? (Introduction) - (First webinar in a 3-part series)
In association with the Louisiana Department of Education's Alternate Pencil Project, Dr. Vicky Roy produced this webinar which provides an introduction to the use of "alternate pencil strategies" for students who cannot access the full alphabet in typical manners.
In order to view this webinar, you must first download the AT&T participant software at the following website: http://uc.att.com/support/download_attc_participant.html
Please note that this software is only compatible with Windows operating system at this point. You will then be able to open and SAVE the webinar file to your PC for viewing by clicking on the following address:
http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Literacy%20writing/Alternate%20Pencil%20(Introduction)%20November%202010.vcr
The handout for the November 2010 webinar can be accessed by clicking here: Alternate Pencil: Why Bother? (Introduction) Handout
November 2010 Webinar: Alternate Pencil – Getting Started (Second webinar a 3-part series)
In association with the Louisiana Department of Education's Alternate Pencil Project, Dr. Vicky Roy produced this webinar which provides information on basic strategies to use in getting started with the use of alternate pencils for students who cannot access the full alphabet in typical manners.
In order to view this webinar, you must first download the AT&T participant software at the following website: http://uc.att.com/support/download_attc_participant.html
Please note that this software is only compatible with Windows operating system at this point. You will then be able to open and SAVE the webinar file to your PC for viewing by clicking on the following address: http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Alternate%20Pencil/Alternate%20Pencil%20(Getting%20Started).vcr
The handout for the webinar Alternate Pencil (Getting Started) Webinar can be found at the following link: http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Literacy%20writing/Webinar%202%20Alternate%20Pencils%20-%20Getting%20Starting.pdf
April 5, 2010 Webinar: Alternate Pencils: Advanced Strategies (Third webinar in a 3-part series)
In association with the Louisiana Department of Education's Alternate Pencil Project, Dr. Vicky Roy produced this webinar which addresses advanced strategies in supporting students' use of an "alternate pencil."
In order to view this webinar, you must first download the AT&T participant software at the following website: http://uc.att.com/support/download_attc_participant.html
Please note that this software is only compatible with Windows operating system at this point. You will then be able to open and SAVE the webinar file to your PC for viewing by clicking on the following address:
http://sda.doe.louisiana.gov/ResourceFiles/Alternate%20Pencil/Alternate%20Pencil%203.vcr
Note that there is a "false start" to this webinar. The webinar does not actually begin until one minute and 45 seconds into the session, and the screen image (PowerPoint slide program) does not begin until two minutes and thirty-one seconds into the session.
The handout for the April 5, 2010, webinar can be reached here: Alternate Pencils" Moving beyond "Let's Write"
|
|
|